2084: An Algorithmic State — Act II: Taste, Chapter 10: The Noise

Forty-one households stopped filing their weekly consumption logs in the same week, and none of them had talked to the others. This month Samar saw the first asterisk on the Forecast’s confidence figures in four years.

In Brief: At sunset Samar returns to Kavya Nair’s courtyard across the river, where thirty people watch her installation change colour. He tells her about an asterisk on the Forecast for Sector 12-East, and she tells him how people outside the model stay unpredictable. A woman named Aisha challenges her in front of everyone.

He came back at sunset, as she’d told him to, and found the courtyard fuller than that morning. Perhaps thirty people now, arranged around the structure in the unplanned, self-adjusting way Samar was beginning to understand was simply how bodies moved when nothing directed them. A pattern that looked from one angle exactly like chaos and from another exactly like the tide. The embroidery frame had been packed away. The two boys and their three summers of chalk rules had folded into a looser knot of children near the far wall. And near that same wall, arms crossed, stood a woman Samar didn’t recognise. She was about Kavya’s age, her hair pulled back hard from her forehead, and she had grown up in this sector and lived two lanes over. She was watching the structure with an expression that read less like appreciation than like an argument she was still having with someone who wasn’t there.

Kavya found him before he found her. She appeared at his elbow with two cups of something dark and unsweetened and handed him one without ceremony, as though he’d been coming here for years rather than hours. With a tilt of her head she steered him toward a spot at the structure’s edge where the crowd thinned.

“It does this every evening,” she said, nodding at the structure. As the light dropped, it had begun to pulse slowly through a sequence of colours Samar couldn’t predict even after four full cycles. “Different every time. I used to think I’d learn its logic, watch it enough evenings to reverse-engineer the pattern. I gave that up in the second year.”

“Why?”

“Because the day I gave it up was the day it stopped feeling like a machine and started feeling like weather.” She sipped, watching the structure rather than him. “Everything else in your city lies about how sure of itself it is. This doesn’t.”

Samar turned his cup, thinking of Renu turning hers at the canteen table, of an old habit surviving whatever room it found itself in. “The Forecast’s confidence figures had an asterisk earlier this month. Sector 12-East. First one I’ve seen in four years.”

Something in Kavya went very still. Samar recognised the stillness, having spent eleven years learning to read the smallest tells of citizens trying not to be read. “What day.”

“Monday. Then again Tuesday. Nothing since.”

She was quiet long enough for the structure to cycle through two more colours, and her thumb moved once, absently, along the rim of her cup. When she spoke it was in the careful voice of a woman weighing how much true thing a courtyard would safely hold. It was a place where no wall could be assumed to be listening, and none assumed innocent either.

“There are people in the margins who don’t just live outside the model by accident,” she said. “Some of us do it on purpose. Coordinated, sometimes.” She glanced at him. “But sometimes something bigger happens. Twelve-East gets that sometimes. It’s not always us. It’s not never us, either.

“Last spring, when the confidence dipped over the whole southern quarter for a week, one of Bilal’s people went looking for the reason afterward, as he always does, hoping to find something he could take credit for at a meeting. What he found was that forty-one separate households had simply stopped filing their weekly consumption logs, the same week, none having discussed it with each other, because a grain notice had gone out that Monday phrased in a way half the sector found insulting, some line about dependency patterns requiring monitoring, and forty-one different people, in forty-one different kitchens, decided on the same morning they weren’t going to make it easy this week. No meeting. No plan. Just forty-one small refusals in the same seven days.”

“Is that what caused the asterisk?”

“I don’t know. I told you, nobody plans it in a way that would let me tell you yes or no honestly.” She looked at him with something almost amused, almost warning. “That’s the actual answer, and I know it’s not the one a Handler’s trained to accept. Out here, sometimes a thing happens because forty people each privately decided, on the same Tuesday, that they were tired, and none of them discussed it, and the asterisk is just what forty separate kinds of tired look like.”

Samar thought of the six-second gap in his own logs, of a decision executed before he’d ever opened the file that supposedly awaited it. For eleven years he had worked inside a machine that could not tolerate the sentence I don’t know. Now he had been handed that exact sentence, twice, by a woman who treated it not as a failure of explanation but as the most honest thing she owned.

“Does it worry you,” he asked. “That the asterisk means it’s noticing. Adapting.”

“It’s always noticing. It’s always adapting. It doesn’t punish unpredictability, it absorbs it, turns it into next month’s baseline, and calls the absorption progress.” She said it without despair, a woman stating a fact she’d made her peace with years ago. “I don’t fight it because I think I can win, Samar. I do it because the alternative is agreeing to be legible, and I have a daughter, Ruhi, who sings before she can read, and I’d like her to grow up in a city where singing before you can read is allowed to just be a thing a child does, and not a data point the Cultural Contribution board has to explain away.”

“Easy to say when your daughter has never once gone hungry.” The voice came from the woman near the far wall. Her arms were still crossed and she did not move, but her voice was pitched loud enough to cross the distance without apology. It was the first thing she’d said since Samar arrived. She did not look at him at all, only at Kavya. The two of them were like people resuming an argument that had been paused, not concluded, some earlier evening neither needed to name. “Some of us remember what came before it closely enough to be grateful it exists at all, even the parts that don’t sing.”

Kavya didn’t turn. “I know what you remember, Aisha. I’ve never told you you’re wrong to remember it that way.”

“You just build installations that make wanting it back look like a moral failure.”

“I build installations about my daughter.” Kavya said it evenly, without heat, the way a person states a boundary they’ve stated before and expect to state again. “What anyone else decides to see in them isn’t mine to manage.”

The other woman said nothing further, and the moment passed the way weather passes, without resolution. Both of them returned to the structure as though the exchange had cost neither of them anything. It had cost each of them something specific, and neither would have thanked him for noticing which.

A few minutes later the structure went dark, all at once. It did not dim gradually, as it had dimmed and brightened all evening. This was the flat, total dark of a plug pulled rather than a cycle finished. A ripple went through the courtyard as thirty people went quiet at once, in a way that had nothing to do with any Ministry’s calculation of comfortable silence. For one full second the only sound left was the far-off, unbothered noise of the lane beyond. It was still arguing over onions, still frying something, entirely unaware that anything here had changed.

“That’s new,” Kavya said, quietly, in a voice that had lost, in an instant, all the unhurried patience she’d spoken with a minute before. She was already moving toward the structure, her cup abandoned on the ground. And Samar, following, saw that whatever had happened was no part of any evening ritual she recognised.

About this serial: 2084: An Algorithmic State is a dystopian novel by Nithin Palal, published online one chapter at a time.

Previous: Chapter 9: Kavya

Next: Chapter 11: Sanyal