2084: An Algorithmic State — Act IV: Trust, Chapter 25: Dirty Data

Farah and Iqbal, eighteen and twenty-one, walk into the Grid in clothes a size too loose and spend four hours doing nothing at all. At the terminal kiosk, Iqbal has been told to type nothing.

In Brief: After the meeting above the grain market, two siblings from the margins, Farah and Iqbal, cross into the Grid without telling anyone. For four hours they try to behave like nothing the system has a category for. Nine days later, Samar searches the Ministry’s records for what the system made of them.

The two who had spoken quietly in the corner after the meeting were named Farah and Iqbal, siblings, eighteen and twenty-one. What they had agreed to do, Samar learned only after it was already finished, was smaller than anything Bilal had argued for. And it was larger, in its consequences, than anyone in that room had thought to prepare for.

Farah had not slept the night before, and had told herself this was only nerves. By the time she and Iqbal reached the checkpoint, she knew it was not only nerves. Some part of her had known for days. A border that had never logged either of their faces in six years was not the same thing as a border that could not.

The clothes had cost them most of a week’s spare earnings between them. They had bought them that morning from the same stall near the boundary where, though neither of them knew it, Samar had bought his own. The clothes were plain, unremarkable, and a size looser on purpose than either of them usually wore. Iqbal had read somewhere that a body dressed slightly wrong drew less attention than a body dressed slightly too well. The checkpoint took them without comment. A small camera swung their way for less than a second. There was no gate, no challenge. It gave only the flat, unbothered permission of a system that had never been asked to consider two young people from the margins wanting, for four hours, nothing at all.

The Grid, Farah would say later, was the quietest place she had ever stood in while fully awake. In the margins, people spoke of it with a kind of bitter envy, and she had expected peace. What she found was a silence with a texture to it, the silence of a room built to notice exactly how loud you were being. Within the first ten minutes she found herself matching her footsteps, without meaning to, to the pace of the strangers around her. It was the way a person new to a language starts shaping their mouth around its sounds before they have decided to.

They sat on a public bench for forty minutes, not speaking, because speaking felt, absurdly, like the loudest thing either of them could do. Iqbal bought food from a stall, and neither of them touched it. Watching the coins change hands without incident, Farah knew they had likely been logged, matched and filed somewhere already. That fact changed nothing about what they had agreed to do, and everything about how her chest felt doing it. They walked the same stretch of Rajpath three times, at three different, uneven paces. Iqbal had insisted on this, and Farah had privately thought it absurd until she was actually doing it. With each change of pace she felt the strange vertigo of a body trying to be nothing a pattern could hold, in a place built entirely from patterns held successfully.

The worst four minutes were the ones at the terminal kiosk. Iqbal’s hands hovered over a keyboard he had been told, precisely, to type nothing into. A queue formed politely behind him, and no one in it said a single impatient word. The Grid extended its whole considerable patience, without any suspicion at all, to a young man from the margins. Any Handler in the building would have taken perhaps four seconds to flag what he was doing, had any Handler been looking. That was the entire, fragile point of the four hours. That day, none of them had reason to be.

They left as they had come, uncommented on, unremarked. Crossing back into the noise and smell and unmodelled chaos of her own lane, Farah had never in her life been so glad of noise.

“That’s the whole plan,” Kavya said, when Farah told them two days later, in the courtyard. Farah’s voice had an unsteadiness that suggested she had not slept much since. “Two unmodelled bodies inside the Grid for four hours, behaving like nothing the system had ever built a category for. Not protest. Not damage. Just... presence, without pattern.”

“Why,” Samar asked.

“Because Aisha’s right that a plan can be eaten,” Iqbal said. He sat close to his sister, and both of them were younger than Samar had expected, given what they had done. “But she said it herself: the tap survived six years because nobody decided it together. So we didn’t decide it together either. We just did it, the two of us, and told no one until after, so there’d be nothing for anyone to organise around, even if it went wrong.”

Zainab had fed them both that evening and had taken nothing for it. The same week, Manzoor had put a new washer in the tap at the back of Fatima’s stall. He refused the money twice and then a third time. After that it stopped being offered, because a fourth time would have been an insult. None of it was a transaction in any sense the Pranaali used. None of it appeared anywhere.

“Did it go wrong.”

Farah’s hands, resting in her lap, were very still. “We don’t know yet. It’s kept me up.”

The answer took nine days to arrive. When it came, it came through Samar, because he was the only person any of them knew with legitimate access to a Ministry terminal. And in the weeks since the checkpoint, he had begun to think of that access less as a privilege the Ministry had granted him and more as a tool. He had simply not yet finished learning its edges.

He found the entry in a sector-wide anomaly digest he had no formal reason to be reading. It was filed under a heading that told him, before he had read a word of it, that Farah and Iqbal’s four unremarkable hours had not passed unnoticed after all.

Sector 3 (Lutyens Grid, Rajpath corridor): two unregistered individuals, biometric match: none on file. Behavioural profile: non-hostile, non-acquisitive, extended duration, no legible objective. Flagged for pattern review. Insufficient recurrence at present to warrant active investigation. Recommend passive monitoring: match against future unregistered entries for possible recurring pattern.

Samar read the last line once. He made himself stop before the old habit could take hold. It would have dragged him back through the line a second and third time, for no reason beyond the comfort of the repetition. On the single reading he allowed himself, he saw that Aisha had been both entirely right and not quite right enough. The system had not been fooled. It had not mistaken Farah and Iqbal’s unmodelled four hours for nothing worth noting. But neither had it panicked, or escalated, or done anything that looked, from the outside, like alarm. It had simply filed them as two data points, not recurrent enough on their own to justify the resource of active pursuit. Then it had set itself, patiently, to wait and see whether the pattern repeated.

Passive monitoring. Match against future unregistered entries.

This was worse than either an arrest or an indifference would have been, and he knew exactly why. The system had not decided Farah and Iqbal were nothing. It had decided they might, one day, become something. The file it had opened would sit quietly, without urgency, waiting for precisely the second unmodelled entry. A movement, any movement, however careful, however unorganised, would eventually produce that entry, given enough years and enough members trying the same small unmeasured thing.

He told Kavya that evening, in the courtyard, and watched her take it in with the same stillness she had shown over the junction box. It was the stillness of someone doing arithmetic she had done many times before, and had hoped, this once, not to have to do again.

“So it waits,” she said finally. “Organise, and it eats the organisation. Don’t organise, and it opens a file and waits.”

“Aisha said the accumulation was the actual defence. Small, unconnected choices.”

“Aisha’s right that it’s the only defence that’s ever worked as long as it has. She didn’t say it was permanent. Nothing out here has ever been permanent. That’s rather the whole point of the place.” Kavya looked toward the installation, dark now, its power steady since the re-route. She was thinking, as he was, of that machine a few feet away, built specifically to admit it did not understand what it was watching. And she was thinking of a file, somewhere in a Ministry server, built specifically to insist that eventually, given patience, it would.

“What do we tell Farah and Iqbal?”

“The truth. That nothing has happened to them yet. And that they should hear the yet.” She said this without despair, in the tone she reserved for the truest things she knew.

About this serial: 2084: An Algorithmic State is a dystopian novel by Nithin Palal, published online one chapter at a time.

Previous: Chapter 24: The Unwritten

Next: Chapter 26: Director Rao