One Rupee, Two Ledgers — Why a Third of Karnataka's SC and ST Fund Is Booked to the Guarantees
Satyameva Jayate · Karnataka
As of 16 November 2026.
A Karnataka law reserves 24.1% of plan spending for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Since 2023, budgets have assigned about a third of it to guarantees that eligible families of every community receive. A special audit was announced on 12 November 2026.
In Brief: A 2013 Karnataka law reserves for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes a share of plan spending equal to their share of the population, which is 24.1%. In four budgets since 2023, reports of budgets and action plans show ₹11,144 crore to ₹15,066 crore a year of it assigned to the five guarantees. These are budget assignments. I found no audited figure for what was finally booked. Section 7(c) of the Act permits a proportionate share of schemes in five named social sectors. Section 15 asks that every scheme give a direct, countable benefit and have the potential to bridge gaps. The counts show the benefit reaching SC and ST families for four guarantees. I found no study of whether it narrows a gap. Every eligible family receives the same sum, which neither proves nor disproves it. Power, grain and bus travel are also hard to place among the five sectors. The BJP government before it booked canals and pipelines to the same fund under another clause, on a smaller reported scale and with no count of who gained. A committee of the Legislature called ten years of this a violation. A special audit was announced on 12 November 2026.
In four budgets since 2023, Karnataka has booked about one rupee in three of its SC and ST sub-plan to guarantees that eligible families of every community receive. The benefit reaches SC and ST families. Whether it narrows the gap the fund exists to close has not been measured. That is my reading of the record, and this article sets out the numbers behind it. They are budget assignments and not audited spending. No court that I can find has held the practice unlawful, and three of the five schemes are hard to place in the words of the clause the Government relies on. The party that follows the practice also wrote the law and removed the clause its rival had used. The BJP government used that clause for four years and kept it. The standard I apply is the Act's own. Does the money give a direct benefit that can be counted, and has it the potential to bridge a gap? The first is shown for four schemes out of five. On the second, equal sums neither prove nor disprove it, and I found no study.
The record at a glance. Each row is argued in the Part that follows.
Question | Short answer | What it rests on |
What does the law reserve? | 24.1% of plan outlay, ₹44,632 crore in 2026-27 | The Act and budget figures as reported |
How much was assigned to the guarantees? | ₹51,521 crore to ₹54,375 crore in four budgets, about a third each year | Press reports of budgets and ministers' replies |
Is that money spent? | Not known. The figures are budget assignments. No audited figure was found | My reading of what the reports are |
Does the law allow it? | Clause 7(c) allows a 24.1% share of schemes in five named sectors. Power, grain and bus travel are not among the names. No court has ruled | The Act |
Does the benefit reach SC and ST families? | Yes for four guarantees, by the Government's count. Shakti has no count | Replies in the Legislative Council as reported |
Does it bridge a gap, as section 15 asks? | Not known. No outcome study found. Equal sums neither prove nor disprove it | My reading |
Did the BJP government do the same? | It booked public works to the fund under clause 7(d), about a tenth of it in the years reported | One newspaper's account of official data |
Has anyone objected officially? | A national commission asked for a report and a committee of the Legislature called it misuse, both in July 2024 | Press reports |
What has changed? | Clause 7(d) was removed in 2024. A special audit and a review by ministers were announced in November 2026 | The Act and three reports |
Five fixed terms are used in this article, with the same meaning across the series. A guarantee is one of the five schemes Congress promised in 2023: Gruha Lakshmi, Gruha Jyothi, Anna Bhagya, Yuva Nidhi and Shakti. A promise is a commitment with a date, made in a manifesto, a cabinet order or a speech by a named office-holder. A record is a document anyone can check, such as a statute, court order, audit report, official dataset or Assembly reply. A news report points to a record. It is not one. Reach is the share of the people a promise named whom the record shows were covered, always with both numbers. Committed spending is salaries, pensions and interest: recurring costs that a government cannot easily cut within a year. The law speaks of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, shortened here to SC and ST. These are legal lists. Dalit and Adivasi are names that many of these communities use for themselves, and not all of them do. I use the two words where the reports do.
Eight more terms a reader will meet.
Term | Plain meaning |
Sub-plan | The part of the State's plan spending that the law reserves for SCs and STs. There are two, one for each. It is a label on part of the plan. It is not a separate account |
Plan outlay | The pool of development spending on which the 24.1% is worked out. It leaves out salaries, pensions, interest and other fixed costs |
Clause (c) | Section 7(c) of the Act. It lets a share of a general social scheme be counted as sub-plan spending |
Deemed expenditure | Section 7(d), now removed. It let a part of a canal or a road be counted as spent on SCs and STs with no list of who gained |
Section 15 | The Act's test for any scheme: a direct and quantifiable benefit, and the potential to bridge gaps in development |
Assigned, booked or charged to the sub-plan | Entered in a budget or action plan as SC and ST spending. It describes a label. It does not describe a second payment |
Budgeted, released, spent, received | Four stages of a rupee. A budget is a plan. A release leaves the treasury. Spending is what the accounts record. Received is what reaches a person |
Additionality | Whether a rupee buys something the person would not have had without it. The word is mine. The Act speaks of bridging gaps |
Opening — Three weeks in July 2024: a plan, a letter and the word "misuse"
In the first week of July 2024 the council that runs Karnataka's SC and ST sub-plan met under the Chief Minister, Siddaramaiah, and approved the plan for the year. The fund stood at ₹39,121.46 crore. Of that, ₹14,730.53 crore was assigned to the five guarantees. Deccan Herald's headline did the sum for its readers: 37%. The Chief Minister's answer was one line. "Through guarantees, we're providing benefits to SC/STs."⁹
On 9 July the National Commission for Scheduled Castes, a body set up under the Constitution, wrote to the State's Chief Secretary. It acted on its own after reading press reports, and it asked for a report on the decision to use ₹14,730.53 crore of sub-plan money for the guarantees. The letter was signed by a Joint Secretary, Rajeev Kumar Tiwari¹¹.
In the same month the Social Welfare Minister, H.C. Mahadevappa, stood in the Legislative Council with numbers of his own. He said 101.22 lakh SC and ST people drew grain under Anna Bhagya and 31.12 lakh SC and ST women drew ₹2,000 a month under Gruha Lakshmi¹⁰. It was the first count of SC and ST people to be set against the guarantees' share of the fund.
On Thursday 25 July the Legislature's own Committee on the Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes placed its report. Using sub-plan money for general programmes, it said, "amounts to misuse and violation of the law". The money "must be used for SC/STs by framing programmes". It said the violation had gone on for a decade, "which is punishable", and it asked for clause (c) of section 7 to be scrapped¹¹. Ten years from 2024 reaches back through the BJP government of 2019 to 2023, the coalition before it and the Congress government that wrote the law.
So within three weeks one decision was read in three ways. The Government said the money reached the people it was meant for, and brought a count. The Commission asked for an explanation. The Legislature's committee used the word misuse. A commission's question is not a verdict, and a committee's conclusion is not a court's finding. All three were looking at the same rupee, and each was right about something. The Parts that follow take them in turn: what the law reserves, how much was assigned, whether it reaches, what the previous government did with the same fund, and who waits while the argument goes on.
What this article does not show should be stated at the start. The year-wise figures come from newspaper reports of budgets, action plans and ministers' replies, and I have not read the State's own sub-plan budget volumes. Where two figures exist for a year I give both. The figures show what was assigned. They do not show what was spent. Nothing here shows that a named hostel, scholarship or loan scheme was cut because of the charge. And nothing here measures whether the fund has changed the lives it was meant for, in either direction.
Part One — A fund sized to 24.1% of the people, and four doors out of it
The idea is fifty years old and began in Delhi. The Planning Commission asked states to draw up a sub-plan for tribal areas from 1974 and a Special Component Plan for Scheduled Castes from 1979-80. The second was renamed the Scheduled Castes Sub-Plan in 2006³⁰. The principle was simple. If a group is a sixth of the people, at least a sixth of the development budget should be spent on it, and spent in ways that reach it.
The Planning Commission's rules were strict on paper. Its 2006 guidelines said that only schemes which "ensure direct benefits to individuals or families belonging to scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes" should be counted. They said large infrastructure "may not be classified under SCSP and TSP". They asked for separate budget heads, numbered 789 and 796, "to ensure their non-divertibility"³⁰. A further memorandum of 11 February 2014 repeated the point: "The funds so earmarked shall be non-divertible", and the test of a scheme was "direct and quantifiable benefits to SC/ST individuals"³¹. These were instructions from a planning body. A state that ignored them broke no law.
Karnataka turned the instruction into a statute. The Karnataka Scheduled Castes Sub-Plan and Tribal Sub-Plan (Planning, Allocation and Utilization of Financial Resources) Act, 2013 is Karnataka Act 65 of 2013. The Governor gave assent on 26 December 2013. A Congress government under Siddaramaiah passed it, and Karnataka was the second state to make such a law, after Andhra Pradesh⁵ ⁹. That credit belongs to the party whose later use of the fund this article examines.
The Act prints no percentage. Section 13 says the State must earmark money "proportionate to the Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribe population of the State"⁵. By the 2011 census that is reported as 17.15% for Scheduled Castes and 6.95% for Scheduled Tribes, which makes 24.1%²². The share is not taken on the whole budget. It is taken on the plan outlay, which leaves out salaries, pensions, interest and other fixed costs. In 2026-27 the sub-plan is ₹44,632 crore¹⁹, which implies a base of about ₹1.85 lakh crore. The division is mine.
Section 7 decides what may be counted
A fund is only as firm as the rule for what counts as spending from it. Section 7 of the Act gave four routes⁵.
Clause | What may be counted | What must be shown | Status |
7(a) | A scheme that benefits only SC or ST persons or households. The whole cost counts | The scheme is for them alone | In force |
7(b) | A scheme for SC or ST habitations. The whole cost counts there, and a proportionate cost in mixed habitations | Where the habitation is and who lives in it | In force |
7(c) | "General social sector schemes, that is education, health, women and child, labour, physically handicapped", which benefit SC or ST persons or households "along with others". The cost is booked "in proportion to the Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribe population" | That the scheme is in a named sector. The share is fixed by population, so no list of names is asked for | In force |
7(d) | A work that cannot be divided, such as a canal, a reservoir or a road. "A portion of the scheme cost as may be determined by the Government" was deemed to be spent on SCs and STs | Nothing about who used the work | Removed in 2024 |
Source: the Act as amended⁵. The third column is my summary.
Clauses (a) and (b) are the fund as most people imagine it: a hostel, a scholarship, a road into a colony. Clauses (c) and (d) are the two doors through which general spending could enter. Under (d) nobody had to show that a Dalit or Adivasi family drew water from the canal. Dalit organisations asked for years that it be removed.
The Congress government removed it. The Assembly passed an amending Bill in 2023, and Karnataka Act 6 of 2024 received assent on 3 February 2024. It deletes clause (d) and adds the Deputy Chief Minister and the Tribal Welfare Minister to the bodies that run the sub-plan⁵ ²⁷. The previous government had not done this though its own SC and ST legislators had asked. On this point Karnataka is also ahead of its neighbour. Telangana's law of 2017 on the same subject still allows a deemed portion for works that cannot be divided³².
The Act defines the fund in one line. It is "a portion of the total plan outlays of the State"⁵. That matters for everything that follows. The sub-plan is not a separate account with its own cash. It is a label on part of the plan, and the argument in this article is about what may carry the label.
Section 15 sets the test for a scheme. The sub-plans "shall include only such schemes that secure direct and quantifiable benefit" to SC or ST persons, households, habitations or tribal areas, "and that have the potential to bridge the gaps in the development"⁵. There are two tests in that sentence. The first asks whether a benefit can be counted. The second asks whether it narrows a distance. The Parts that follow apply both.
The Act also says who must keep the account. A State Council chaired by the Chief Minister approves each year's plan, and a Nodal Agency under the Social Welfare Minister applies section 7. Under section 6 the Nodal Agency must keep details by scheme, district, village and beneficiary, run a web portal that tracks spending, outputs and outcomes, and "facilitate at least annual social auditing" of the money. Under section 26 it must place before the Legislature each year a report on outcomes and unused funds⁵. So the public account that critics ask for is already a duty in the law. Section 13 lets an unspent amount be added to the next year's allocation and carried no further. Section 24 makes wilful neglect of duty by an official punishable with up to six months in prison⁵. The word "non-divertible" does appear in the Act, in its statement of purpose. No operative section uses it.
What the manifestos of 2023 said about the fund
They said almost nothing, and that is worth a table. I read the three main parties' manifestos for the 2023 election for any line on the sub-plan.
Party | What its manifesto says | Kind of statement |
Congress | "To set up Rs. 1000 Crore revolving fund - "Dr Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar Entrepreneurship Fund" - for organizing entrepreneurship development and incubation programs for SC entrepreneurs." (page 15) | A promise for SC entrepreneurs. No line on the sub-plan in the 25-page edition I read |
BJP | "Since 2019-20, we have allocated more than ₹1 lakh crore towards SCSP and TSP, of which more than ₹78 thousand crore have been allocated towards SCSP and more than ₹32 thousand crore have been allocated towards TSP." (PDF page 18) | A claim about its record. No promise on how the fund would be used |
JD(S) | Capital of up to ₹5 crore at 2% interest for SC and ST entrepreneurs and contractors, and a cut in the State Financial Corporation's rate for them from 4% to 2% (page 9, in Kannada) | A promise. The English is my rendering. No line on the sub-plan |
Sources: the three manifestos³⁶ ³⁷ ³⁸.
Two things follow. The Congress manifesto promised the five guarantees and did not tell the voter that part of their cost would be entered against the SC and ST fund. And no party promised to close clause (c) or clause (d). The BJP's claim about its own record is tested in Part Four.
Figure 1 · Thirteen years of one fund: reserved in 2013, charged to canals, then to guarantees, and sent for audit in 2026

What to see: eight dated events from 2013 to 2026. Steps that tightened or defended the reservation are above the line. Uses of the fund and objections to them are below it.
Source: the Act, and the reports cited in this article.
So the law holds three ideas at once. One is a fund kept apart for a people. The second, in clause (c), is a way to count a slice of a general social scheme as part of that fund. The third, in section 15, is a test that every scheme must pass. In 2023 the Government brought the five guarantees in through clause (c). Whether all five fit its words, and whether they pass the test, is taken up in the next two Parts.
Part Two — About ₹54,000 crore in four budgets, and one reserved rupee in three
The first assignment came within weeks of the new government's first budget. In August 2023 it was reported that ₹11,144 crore of the year's sub-plan of ₹34,294 crore was assigned to the guarantees⁷ ⁸. Every budget since has repeated the practice. The table gives the four years, with a second reported figure where one exists.
Year | Sub-plan (₹ crore) | Assigned to the guarantees (₹ crore) | Share | A second reported figure |
2023-24 | 34,294 | 11,144 | 32.5% | None found |
2024-25 | 39,121.46 | 14,730.53 | 37.7% | 14,281, the Minister's figure in the Legislative Council |
2025-26 | 42,017.51 | 13,433.84 | 32.0% | 11,896.84, the action plan of July 2025 |
2026-27 | 44,632 | 15,066.46 | 33.8% | 14,198.93, in a second report of the same budget |
Sources: reports of the budgets, action plans and ministers' replies⁷ ⁸ ⁹ ¹⁰ ¹³ ¹⁵ ¹⁶ ¹⁹ ²⁰. The shares are my arithmetic on the higher figure.
Figure 2 · About one rupee in three of the SC and ST sub-plan has been assigned to the five guarantees in every budget since 2023

What to see: the whole sub-plan as a bar for each year, with the part assigned to the guarantees in orange and its share written above. The share has not fallen below 32% on the higher figures.
Source: budget and action-plan figures as reported by The News Minute, Deccan Herald and Telangana Today, 2023 to 2026.
A word on what kind of rupee these are. Each figure is an assignment made in a budget or an action plan. None is an audited amount spent. A rupee passes through stages: budgeted, approved in the action plan, released, spent and received. Every figure in the table is at the first or second stage, and 2026-27 is a year still running. The auditor reports what the five guarantees cost in 2024-25 and does not say how much of that cost was booked under the sub-plan¹. For 2023-24 the sub-plan cell's own table later shows a final allocation of ₹35,221.84 crore and ₹34,245.77 crore spent, without a line for the guarantees⁶. For 2024-25 one newspaper reported in July 2025 that the Government told the Assembly the amount finally used for the guarantees was ₹9,797 crore¹⁵. I have not seen that reply and do not rely on it. If it is right, about a third of the assignment for that year was not used, and that would be a fact in the Government's favour which it has not publicised.
Added up, the four budgets assign between ₹51,521 crore and ₹54,375 crore, on the lower and the higher figures. The addition is mine. On 19 December 2025 a BJP leader said ₹39,000 crore meant for Dalits had been "used" for guarantees in three years²⁸. That is a party's claim. It is close to the sum of the first three budget figures, which is ₹39,308 crore, and it treats an assignment as an amount spent.
The first year's split shows where the weight falls. Gruha Lakshmi took ₹5,075 crore, Anna Bhagya ₹2,779 crore, Gruha Jyothi ₹2,410 crore, Shakti ₹812 crore and Yuva Nidhi ₹67.50 crore⁷ ⁸.
Figure 3 · Gruha Lakshmi took nearly half of the sub-plan money assigned to the guarantees in 2023-24

What to see: the ₹11,144 crore of 2023-24 split by scheme. The monthly cash for women is the largest line, as it is in the cost of the guarantees as a whole.
Source: The News Minute, 4 August 2023, and The South First, 2 August 2023, from the Government's figures.
The Government heard the objection, and the figure still rose
The objections of July 2024 were set out in the Opening. I have found no reply from the State to the National Commission and no order that followed its letter. The Legislature's committee returned to the subject in December 2024. It said the charge for 2024-25 should have been ₹12,532 crore, which is 24.1% of the guarantee budget, and not ₹14,730.53 crore¹². That is a narrower complaint than its first. It accepts that some of the cost may be charged and disputes how much.
The Government moved part of the way. In March 2025 Deccan Herald reported that the Social Welfare Department, now holding counts of SC and ST beneficiaries, wanted the charge for four guarantees tied to those counts and the charge for Shakti capped at 24.1% for want of data¹². The 2025-26 budget then assigned ₹13,433.84 crore, about 6% less than the comparable figure of ₹14,282.38 crore for the year before¹³. The action plan of July 2025 went lower, to ₹11,896.84 crore, or 28% of the fund¹⁵ ¹⁶. In the Assembly on 20 August 2025 the opposition used the higher figure, and the Minister defended the practice without disputing the amount¹⁷.
The next budget reversed the direction. On 6 March 2026 the assignment for 2026-27 was set at ₹15,066.46 crore, the highest yet: ₹10,789.58 crore from the Scheduled Castes Sub-Plan and ₹4,276.88 crore from the Tribal Sub-Plan¹⁹ ²⁶. A second report gives ₹14,198.93 crore, with a smaller line for Gruha Lakshmi²⁰. The two differ by ₹867.53 crore, and I could not settle the difference without the budget volume.
Is this "diversion"? The word is the opposition's and the headline writers', and the Government rejects it. I do not use it in my own voice. Diversion suggests that money left the people it was meant for, and the Government's case is that it did not. So I write that the money was assigned, booked or charged to the guarantees, and I leave the reader to judge the word after Part Three. I found no court order on the practice. That is a statement about what I found and not about the courts. A commission's letter and a committee's report are not rulings.
Clause (c) names five sectors, and three guarantees are hard to place in them
The legal question is narrower than the political one, and it has two parts. Clause (c) covers "general social sector schemes, that is education, health, women and child, labour, physically handicapped"⁵. The words "that is" read like a closed list. Free power is an energy scheme, free grain is a food scheme and free bus travel is a transport scheme, and none of those sectors is named. The table sets each guarantee against the clause and against the two tests of section 15.
Guarantee | What it gives, and the department | Is its sector named in clause (c)? | Direct and quantifiable benefit? | Potential to bridge a gap? |
Gruha Lakshmi | ₹2,000 a month to women who head households. Women and Child Development | Clear: "women and child" | Shown. Counted, and the 2025-26 charge matches the count | Arguable either way. No outcome study |
Yuva Nidhi | An allowance to unemployed graduates and diploma holders. Skill development | Arguable, under "labour" or "education" | Shown. Counted | Arguable either way. No outcome study |
Shakti | Free bus travel for women. Transport | Not clear. Transport is not named. It could be argued under "women and child" | Not shown. No count exists | Not shown |
Anna Bhagya | Free grain. Food and Civil Supplies | Not clear. Food is not named | Shown. Counted | Arguable either way. No outcome study |
Gruha Jyothi | Free power up to a limit. Energy | Not clear. Energy is not named | Shown. Counted | Arguable either way. No outcome study |
Source: the Act⁵ and the counts in Part Three. Every cell in the last three columns is my reading. I am not a lawyer and I have not read the rules made under the Act. Only a court or the Legislature can settle the point.
The Minister says clause (c) requires what the Government does¹⁷. In the reports I read, the Government has not said which words of the clause cover power, grain or bus travel. That is the first question I would put to the Nodal Agency.
The second part is the amount. Clause (c) says the cost is to be booked "in proportion to the Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribe population", which is 24.1% of what a scheme costs. The Legislature's committee used exactly that arithmetic in December 2024. Set the charge against the audited cost of the five guarantees. In 2023-24 they cost ₹34,859 crore, and ₹11,144 crore is about 32% of that. In 2024-25 they cost ₹52,526 crore, and ₹14,730.53 crore is about 28%¹. Both shares are above 24.1%. The comparison sets a budget assignment against an audited cost, so it is indicative and the arithmetic is mine. It raises the question whether the charge ran ahead of the share the clause allows in the first two years. It does not settle it. A like-for-like check needs the budget estimate for the schemes, or the amount finally booked under the sub-plan.
Why a government under pressure reaches for this fund is my inference. No official reason is on record in what I read. The auditor puts the cost of the five guarantees at ₹52,525.60 crore in 2024-25, about a fifth of the State's revenue receipts¹. The State has run a revenue deficit in every year since they began. A finance department that must find that sum looks first at money already in the budget, and the largest pool set apart by law was this one. I have not put the question to the Finance Department. It should be asked how each scheme was classified, and why.
Part Three — The rupee reaches her. Does the reservation?
The Government's defence deserves to be heard in its best form before anything is said against it.
The Chief Minister's line of July 2024 was that the guarantees themselves deliver benefits to SCs and STs⁹. The Social Welfare Minister put the legal case in the Assembly in August 2025. Under a general scheme, he said, sub-plan money goes only to SC and ST beneficiaries, so it is neither misuse nor diversion. Clause (c) of the Act requires exactly this. The Union government and other states do the same. And he would use the Act's penal section against departments that failed to supply beneficiary data¹⁷. He gave the same answer in the Legislative Council in December 2025¹⁸. A department official called the matter "a zero-sum game": once 24.1% is reserved by law, some of it must flow through general schemes, because targeted schemes cannot absorb it all¹⁴. And the party points out that it wrote the law in 2013, when nothing was reserved by statute at all.
There is a further point in the Government's favour which its ministers have not made, and I add it. The first test of section 15 is a "direct and quantifiable benefit"⁵. A monthly credit of ₹2,000 to a named Dalit woman's bank account meets that test better than almost anything that has been charged to this fund in ten years. It is direct. It is quantifiable. A canal was neither.
The counts are real. The Minister tabled them in the Legislative Council in July 2024¹⁰.
Guarantee | SC and ST beneficiaries | Of whom ST | Set against all beneficiaries |
Anna Bhagya (grain) | 101.22 lakh people | 30.16 lakh | Total not given in the reply as reported |
Gruha Lakshmi (₹2,000 a month) | 31.12 lakh women | 8.67 lakh | About 25% of some 1.23 crore women |
Gruha Jyothi (free power) | 13.90 lakh households | 4.04 lakh | About 8.5% of some 1.63 crore households |
Yuva Nidhi (unemployed graduates) | 44,538 young people | 16,262 | Total not given |
Shakti (free bus travel) | No count | No count | Not applicable |
Sources: the Minister's reply as reported, and a later report for the Gruha Lakshmi total¹⁰ ¹². The shares in the last column are my arithmetic.
Figure 4 · What the record shows about the sub-plan and the guarantees, and where it stops

What to see: solid arrows are steps the public record supports. Dashed arrows are steps I could not trace. The counts in the table above belong to the lower blue box. Nothing in this article reaches either box on the right.
Source: my summary of the reports, counts and audit cited in this article.
One row raises a question and does not answer it. SC and ST people are 24.1% of the State's population and about a quarter of Gruha Lakshmi's women. They are about 8.5% of Gruha Jyothi's households on these counts. Neither comparison is like for like. A share of the population is not the share of women who head households, or of households with an electricity connection in their own name. So the low figure does not show that Gruha Jyothi under-reaches Dalit and Adivasi homes. It may reflect an incomplete count, fewer meters in their names, or more tenants. The right comparison is with the SC and ST share of households that are connected and eligible, and I do not have it. It is a question for the energy department.
For Gruha Lakshmi the amount can be checked against the count. At ₹2,000 a month, 31.12 lakh women cost about ₹7,469 crore a year. The sub-plan charge for Gruha Lakshmi in 2025-26 was reported as ₹7,438 crore¹⁵. The two match closely. That year the Government charged the fund what SC and ST women were in fact paid, and it deserves credit for a count that made the check possible. The charge for 2026-27 is ₹9,193.85 crore¹⁹. At the same rate that needs about 38 lakh women. I found no count that high. Either the number of SC and ST women on the rolls has grown by more than a fifth, or the charge has moved ahead of the count.
Figure 5 · The 2025-26 charge matches the count of SC and ST women. The 2026-27 charge would need about 38 lakh of them

What to see: the yearly cost of paying the counted SC and ST women, beside the sums charged to the sub-plan for Gruha Lakshmi in two budgets. The first two bars are nearly equal. The third is about ₹1,725 crore higher.
Source: Deccan Herald, 19 July 2024 and 7 March 2026, and Telangana Today, 29 July 2025. The first bar is my arithmetic.
Shakti is the weak case. A bus conductor does not record caste, so nobody knows how many of the free journeys are made by SC and ST women. The Government has still charged about ₹1,537 crore a year to the sub-plan for it¹³ ¹⁹. A BJP member of the Council from a Scheduled Tribe, Shantaram Siddi, said that tribal areas have no bus routes to ride on¹⁰. That is one member's statement and no survey stands behind it. Nothing on record answers it either.
The two groups should also be looked at apart, and I can do that only a little. On the counts above, Adivasi beneficiaries are 27.9% of the SC and ST women in Gruha Lakshmi, 29.8% of the people in Anna Bhagya, 29.1% of the households in Gruha Jyothi and 36.5% of the young people in Yuva Nidhi. Their share of the two groups' population is 28.8%. The charge is split in nearly the same ratio: the Tribal Sub-Plan bears 28.4% of the 2026-27 assignment¹⁹. So in these State-wide counts the ST share of recipients is close to its share of the two groups together. That does not show equal access or equal effect, because I lack the eligible population and the district figures for each scheme. The percentages are mine. What State-wide figures cannot show is the difference between a colony in a town and a hamlet in a forest, where a free bus pass or free power is worth little without a bus or a connection. I found no district-wise figures, though section 6 of the Act requires them to be kept.
Then where is the problem? It lies in what the rupee adds, and here I move from the record to my own test. Take two women in the same village who each head a household and meet the scheme's rules. One is Dalit and the other is not. Each receives ₹2,000 a month under Gruha Lakshmi, because the scheme is for every woman who qualifies. The accounting is done for the scheme as a whole. A share of its yearly cost, meant to stand for what SC and ST women are paid, is booked under the sub-plan, and the rest under the general budget. No single payment carries a label, no second payment is made and no money moves between accounts. She receives what her neighbour receives. Had that share been left under the general label, the law would still require 24.1% of the plan to be booked for SCs and STs, and other spending of the same size would have had to be found for them or labelled for them. That is the sense in which the general budget is relieved. I cannot name a programme that went unfunded because of it, and no record I read names one. The rupee reaches her. Whether the reservation does is the question. She is reached as a citizen who qualifies. Whether the fund's own purpose, which is to bridge a gap, is served by a payment her neighbour also receives has not been shown either way.
Figure 6 · One scheme, two labels: a share of the cost is booked under the sub-plan, and every woman who qualifies receives the same sum

What to see: the yearly cost of one guarantee as a single bar, with the share booked under the sub-plan in orange. No money moves between two accounts. The sub-plan is a label on part of the plan, applied to the scheme as a whole and not to any one payment. It is my reading and not a finding of the auditor.
Source: my reading of section 7(c) of the 2013 Act and of the budget figures as reported.
Economists have a word for this. Money is fungible: a rupee marked for one purpose frees another rupee for something else. The best-known test was run on foreign aid. Three World Bank economists studied what governments did when donors gave loans earmarked for a sector. A government, they wrote, "could render earmarked aid fungible by reducing its own resources in the sector that receives aid and transferring them to other sectors of the budget". They found that loans marked for agriculture, education and energy were largely offset in this way, while loans for transport and communication were "fully spent on the purposes intended by donors"³⁵. The sub-plan is an earmark the State places on itself, and the lesson carries over. An earmark protects a group only when it pays for something that would not have been bought without it. I use the study as a lens. It measured aid to countries and did not study Karnataka, so it cannot show that the State's budget behaved in the same way. That would need the appropriations, releases and spending of each department traced across the years.
The Leader of the Opposition in the Council, Chalavadi Narayanaswamy, made the point in fewer words: "Guarantees are being given irrespective of caste."¹⁴ More than one newspaper reports that Dalit leaders inside the Congress have asked their own Chief Minister to scrap clause (c)¹⁴ ¹⁹. The objection is not confined to one party.
The Government has a reply to this reading too, and it is a serious one. Suppose the charge were stopped tomorrow. The law would still require 24.1% of the plan to be booked as SC and ST spending. The departments would have to find about ₹15,000 crore of new targeted schemes in a year, and Part Five shows year-end parking and last-quarter releases in the welfare departments, though the audit does not tie those sums to the sub-plan. A rupee that reaches a Dalit woman's account each month may do her more good than a rupee shown as spent and lying in a corporation's bank. I accept that as a fact about how the State works today. It is an argument for repairing the targeted schemes. It does not show that the reservation was honoured.
One more thing must be said for the guarantee itself, apart from its label. Two thousand rupees in a woman's own account may be worth more to her than the figure suggests, if she is the one who decides how it is spent. Free travel may mean a job or a clinic that was out of reach. These are effects on a woman's life, and they may be larger for a Dalit or Adivasi woman who had less to begin with. The article on the five guarantees sets out the surveys that exist and their limits. If such effects were measured and shown to be larger for SC and ST women, that would be evidence for the second test of section 15, and the Government's case would be stronger than its ministers have made it. I found no such measurement.
What is left when the guarantees are taken out
Subtract the guarantee charge from each year's fund and compare what remains with the whole fund of 2022-23, the last full year before the guarantees.
Figure 7 · After the guarantees, less is left in the sub-plan than the whole fund held in 2022-23

What to see: the grey bar is the whole fund of 2022-23. The blue bars are each later year's fund less the money assigned to the guarantees, on the higher figure. None of the four reaches the grey bar, and prices have risen in between.
Source: SCSP and TSP Cell, Government of Karnataka, and budget figures as reported, 2023 to 2026. The subtraction is mine.
In 2026-27 the remainder is about ₹29,566 crore. The whole fund of 2022-23 was ₹30,263.77 crore⁶. So the headline figure for SC and ST welfare has grown by 47% in four years, and the part not assigned to the guarantees has not grown at all in plain rupees. This is not a measure of targeted spending, and the chart should not be read as one. The fund of 2022-23 also carried deemed spending on works and shares of general schemes, as the next Part shows. A true comparison would split each year's fund by clause: schemes for SC and ST people alone, schemes for their habitations, shares of general schemes, and deemed spending. It would use amounts spent and allow for prices. I could not find that split for any year. The portal that section 6 requires is where it should be.
Part Four — "Not even one paisa was diverted": the BJP years, by the same rule
The rule I apply to both governments is one sentence. Was money reserved under the Act charged to spending that was not designed for SC and ST people alone? For the Congress years the answer is yes, through clause (c). For the BJP years it is also yes, mainly through clause (d).
The charge was first made by the man who later faced it. On 21 April 2022 Siddaramaiah, then Leader of the Opposition, said the BJP government "has betrayed Dalits and Scheduled Tribes". He cited a Deccan Herald report that ₹7,885.32 crore of sub-plan money had been spent between 2018 and 2021 on drinking water, drainage, irrigation and other civil works under the deemed-expenditure clause. He said this "violated the provisions of the Act" and asked for action against officers²¹ ²². A year earlier, when SC and ST legislators of the BJP itself objected to the practice, Chief Minister B.S. Yediyurappa had answered that "not even one paisa was diverted"²³ ²¹.
The figure of ₹7,885.32 crore is attributed to official data which I have not seen, and three things qualify it. The years 2018 to 2021 cover two governments. A Congress and JD(S) coalition held office from May 2018 to July 2019, and the BJP from 26 July 2019 to May 2023. I found no split of the sum between them, so it cannot be laid on the BJP alone. Next, the clause was part of the 2013 Act as Congress wrote it, and using it was lawful. Whether the portion "determined by the Government" was reasonable is another matter. The then minister Govind Karjol said that during the pandemic the Finance Department allowed up to 50%, and later up to 100%, of a work to be counted²¹. Last, the scale. The sub-plan allocations of 2018-19, 2019-20 and 2020-21 add up to about ₹83,032 crore⁶. Set against that, ₹7,885 crore is about 9.5%. The percentage is mine and only indicative, because the years are loosely stated in the report.
That was not the whole of it. One year's plan charged ₹3,307 crore of Jal Jeevan Mission tap connections to the fund²¹. And clause (c) was in use as well. The department's annual report for 2022-23, as one outlet reports it, shows sub-plan money booked against the Prime Minister's crop insurance scheme (₹376.90 crore), PM Kisan (₹129.73 crore), irrigation and horticulture schemes and milk incentives, with counts of SC and ST farmers for each²⁵. Those are general schemes of the Union government, paid to every eligible farmer, charged to the reserved fund for the farmers who were SC or ST. In kind it is the same act as charging Gruha Lakshmi. In size it is far smaller.
"More than ₹1 lakh crore": the BJP's own claim, tested
The BJP's 2023 manifesto said that since 2019-20 it had allocated more than ₹1 lakh crore to the two sub-plans³⁷. The sub-plan cell's table bears the number out. The table does not print its units, and I read them as crore of rupees because they match the budget figures reported elsewhere.
Year | Government in office | Allocation (₹ crore) | Shown as spent (₹ crore) | Share spent |
2017-18 | Congress | 27,962.34 | 26,203.64 | 93.71% |
2018-19 | Congress and JD(S) coalition | 29,694.48 | 27,518.04 | 92.67% |
2019-20 | Coalition to July 2019, then BJP | 27,391.82 | 25,851.10 | 94.38% |
2020-21 | BJP | 25,945.90 | 24,646.99 | 94.99% |
2021-22 | BJP | 27,021.62 | 26,018.33 | 96.29% |
2022-23 | BJP | 30,263.77 | 29,353.76 | 97.00% |
2023-24 | Congress | 35,221.84 | 34,245.77 | 97.23% |
Source: SCSP and TSP Cell, Government of Karnataka⁶.
The four years from 2019-20 add up to ₹1,10,623 crore, so the manifesto's sentence is true. It is also less than it sounds, for two reasons. The allocation is not a gift of the government of the day. Section 13 fixes it as a share of the plan, so any government that passes a budget allocates it. And the rupee amount fell in the BJP's first two years, from ₹29,694 crore to ₹25,946 crore, and was only 2% above its 2018-19 level by 2022-23. The fall of 2020-21 came in the pandemic year, when the plan itself shrank, and a fixed share of a smaller plan is a smaller fund. Siddaramaiah's statement in 2022 that the fund had been "reduced" was true of the rupees for those years²².
On one measure the BJP years score well. The share of the allocation shown as spent rose every year, from 94.38% to 97.00%. I give that credit with one caution which applies to every row of the table. "Spent" here includes deemed expenditure on public works and money released to corporations, and Part Five shows that a release is not always a benefit received.
Figure 8 · The sub-plan fell in 2019-21 and has grown every year since. The share spent has stayed above 92% since 2015-16

What to see: the allocation for each year from 2014-15 to 2026-27, coloured by the government in office, with the share shown as spent above each bar where the State reports it. The dip is in 2019-20 and 2020-21.
Source: SCSP and TSP Cell, Government of Karnataka, for 2014-15 to 2024-25. Budget figures as reported for 2025-26 and 2026-27.
Then is the present government in the clear on clause (d)? Not wholly. Mahadevappa told the Assembly in August 2025 that the BJP government had spent ₹8,000 crore through deemed expenditure and "the current government" ₹4,000 crore before the clause was removed¹⁷. The second figure is a minister's statement against his own side, which gives it some weight. I have seen no record behind either figure. A Deccan Herald report written after the 2023 election said "successive governments" had used the clause, and that the new government was at first likely to cap it and not scrap it²⁴. In the end it scrapped it.
The two records can now be set side by side.
Test | BJP government, 2019 to 2023 | Congress government, 2023 onwards |
Main route into the fund | Clause (d), public works. Clause (c) for Union farm schemes | Clause (c), the five guarantees. Clause (d) until February 2024 |
Scale reported | ₹7,885 crore over 2018 to 2021, which includes a coalition year. About 9.5% of three years' fund | ₹11,144 crore to ₹15,066 crore a year. 32% to 38% of each year's fund |
Proof of who gained | None for works. Counts of farmers for the farm schemes, as reported | Counts for four guarantees. None for Shakti |
Size of the fund | Fell for two years, then recovered to ₹30,264 crore | Rose each year, to ₹44,632 crore |
Share shown as spent | 94% to 97% | 97% in 2023-24. Later years not yet reported |
What it did to the law | Kept clause (d), though its own SC and ST legislators objected | Removed clause (d). Kept clause (c), though Dalit leaders in the party objected |
Sources: as cited in this Part and in Parts Two and Three. The reading across the rows is mine.
So the comparison has four lines, and each is my reading. Both governments booked reserved money to spending that was not designed for SCs and STs alone, and the Legislature's committee counted ten years of it. The BJP's main route was weaker on proof, because a canal needed no beneficiary. The Congress amounts are larger on the figures available, in rupees and as a share. And the Congress government closed one of the two doors, while no government has closed the other. The third line needs a caution. The two sets of figures are not matched. One is spending reported for three years under two governments through clause (d). The other is yearly budget assignments through clause (c). A matched comparison would take the same clauses and amounts spent, one year at a time, with the coalition year set apart. I do not have those figures. Until someone publishes them, the difference in scale is an order of magnitude and no more. The same rule gives both results.
The Union government comes into this in two ways. Its schemes were among those charged to the State's fund, as shown above. And the Minister says the Union does in its own budget what Karnataka does in the State's¹⁷. I have not tested the Union's own SC and ST allocations by this rule, and until that is done the claim stands as his.
Part Five — "Mere parking of funds": what the auditor found in the welfare departments
If a third of the fund goes to the guarantees, two thirds still go elsewhere, and the argument for the reservation rests on what that part buys. The Legislature's committee named what it had in mind: basic facilities in hostels, and scholarships¹¹. The Leader of the Opposition in the Council named land, education and schools¹⁴. Dalit leaders asked for larger budgets for the development corporations, which give loans and subsidies for self-employment, and for better food in student hostels. One department source put the corporations' share at about ₹5,000 crore a year where Dalit leaders sought ₹10,000 crore¹⁴. A BJP member told the Assembly in August 2025 that the Social Welfare Department itself received ₹7,072 crore of the ₹42,000 crore fund¹⁷. That is a member's figure, and I could not check it against the budget volume.
The Government has added to the targeted side, and that counts. The action plan of July 2024 raised the monthly aid for SC and ST candidates preparing for the civil services from ₹10,000 to ₹15,000, set ₹91 crore for laptops for postgraduate students, and planned residential schools in 60 hoblis that year⁹. The 2024-25 budget, as the auditor lists it, said ₹2,710 crore had been provided for building residential schools and hostels of the SC, ST, backward class and minority departments¹.
The auditor's review of the Social Welfare grant for 2024-25 shows what happened to some of these departments' money once it was provided¹. The grant covers four departments: Social Welfare, which serves the Scheduled Castes, Tribal Welfare, Backward Classes Welfare and Minorities Welfare. The audit does not say which of the sums below were booked under the sub-plan, so I cannot tie any of them to it. On 30 March 2025, a day before the year closed, the Social Welfare Department moved ₹145 crore into deposit accounts: ₹100 crore to the Dr B.R. Ambedkar Development Corporation and ₹45 crore to the society that runs residential schools. The money came from a provision for allowances on vacant posts. The auditor calls such year-end transfers "mere parking of funds". In the last quarter of the year three departments released ₹760.25 crore to 20 corporations. The corporations under the Social Welfare Department received ₹425 crore, their whole grant for the year, in those three months. Those under the Tribal Welfare Department received ₹82.50 crore of ₹110 crore, which is 75%. Those under the Backward Classes Welfare Department received ₹252.75 crore of ₹337 crore, also 75%.
Figure 9 · Corporations under the Social Welfare Department received their whole year's grant in the last three months of 2024-25

What to see: each department's grant to its corporations for the year, with the part released in the last quarter in orange. The three orange parts add up to ₹760.25 crore. The auditor does not say whether these grants were booked under the sub-plan.
Source: CAG State Finances report 2024-25, Appendix 2.15.
These findings do not show that the guarantees took the money, and they are not findings about the sub-plan as such. They show how the State counts. A rupee is recorded as spent when it leaves the treasury. A student or a borrower counts it when it arrives. The auditor gives one more example from the same grant, and it concerns other communities: ₹412 crore of unused grant lay in the bank accounts of four corporations under the Backward Classes Welfare Department¹. I mention it only to show that the habit is general. For a young Dalit man who wants a loan to start a workshop, the dates matter more than the totals. A corporation that receives its whole grant between January and March cannot lend through the year. A business would say the lender has no working capital for nine months and too much for three. That is my reading of the auditor's dates.
The promises made to such a borrower in 2023 can be checked only in part. The Congress manifesto promised a revolving fund of ₹1,000 crore for SC entrepreneurs³⁶. I could not confirm whether it has been set up. The JD(S) promised cheaper capital for SC and ST entrepreneurs and contractors³⁸, and it has not held office since, so its promise is untested.
The Union government's part is on record too. Under its scheme PM-AJAY it allotted ₹398.95 crore to Karnataka for 2022 to 2025. The first instalment of ₹23.77 crore, received in 2022-23 under the BJP government, was not used. Later instalments were therefore withheld, and only ₹6.01 crore came in 2024-25¹. Two State governments and the Union's release rule share that result. At the council meeting of 12 November 2026 the Chief Minister is reported to have said that ₹1,937 crore of the Union's share of centrally sponsored schemes for 2025-26 was still pending, out of ₹3,497 crore⁴⁰. The report does not say whether the figure is for SC and ST schemes alone, and I have no statement from the Union on it.
Figure 10 · Of ₹399 crore allotted under PM-AJAY, about ₹30 crore reached the State

What to see: the sum allotted beside the two sums that arrived. The first instalment went unused, so the rest was held back under the Union's own rule.
Source: CAG State Finances report 2024-25.
The anganwadi, where two official ledgers do not agree
Pregnant women and children under six depend on the food given at the anganwadi. The auditor names nutrition first among the schemes that lost money as subsidies grew. In its words, "the State was forced to cut down its funds to some of its ongoing schemes such as Nutrition, Assistance to Local Bodies/Corporations/Urban Development Authorities/Slum Improvement Board, Assistance to Gram Panchayats in Rural Development Programmes etc."¹ The sentence gives no rupee amount for any of them, and the press reports of the day carried none⁴. The accounts supply one for rural development as a sector, where revenue spending fell from ₹9,760 crore to ₹8,540 crore in 2024-25². For the nutrition head they show ₹1,451.95 crore spent in 2024-25³, and I do not have the comparable figure for the year before. The Note That Said No, the article on the State's finances in this series, takes up that finding in full.
For the scheme Saksham Anganwadi and Poshan 2.0, which the Union and the State pay for together, the State's share due in 2024-25 was ₹727.90 crore. By the State's accounts, which the report calls VLC figures, ₹311.99 crore was passed on, a shortfall of ₹415.91 crore. By the scheme's own account, as reported on the Union's payment system, ₹721.98 crore was passed on, a shortfall of ₹5.92 crore. The auditor asked the Finance Department for the reasons and was awaiting a reply¹. On the other side, the State spent ₹65.93 crore more than it had budgeted on upgrading anganwadi buildings¹.
Figure 11 · Two official ledgers disagree by ₹410 crore on what was passed on for anganwadi nutrition

What to see: what was due, and what each of two official systems says was passed on. The gap between the two systems is ₹409.99 crore.
Source: CAG State Finances report 2024-25, Table 2.18.
The families this argument leaves out
I cannot state Reach for the targeted schemes, and the gap is itself a finding. I found no published count of hostel seats against applicants, of scholarships paid against students eligible, of land granted against families landless, or of women and children fed at the anganwadi against those enrolled. Section 6 of the Act requires the Nodal Agency to keep such details by scheme, district, village and beneficiary, and to show progress on a web portal. The sub-plan cell's website carries a table of allocation and spending by year. I did not find the rest there. The Government can say how many SC and ST women receive Gruha Lakshmi. On what I could find, it cannot say the same for a hostel bed.
Some families fall outside both halves of the fund. A family in a hamlet with no bus route cannot use Shakti near home, and about ₹1,537 crore of sub-plan money is charged to that scheme each year. I have no route map to say how many such hamlets there are. A landless Dalit labourer is counted among the 101.22 lakh who draw grain, and grain does not become land. A tenant with no meter in her name may fall outside Gruha Jyothi, which may be one reason for the low count noted in Part Three. A student in a hostel is helped by neither the guarantee nor the count. For each of them the question is what the fund bought that the general budget would not have bought, which is where this article began.
Part Six — A label can be changed by a rule: nine repairs, and who can make them
The fund exists because of one sentence in the Constitution. Article 46 says: "The State shall promote with special care the educational and economic interests of the weaker sections of the people, and, in particular, of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes"³³. It is a Directive Principle. It guides governments, and in outline no court can enforce it. Karnataka's Act of 2013 took a part of that duty and gave it a number. A student of law should notice what kind of thing the number is. It is a duty on the State to book a share of its plan in a certain way. It gives no Dalit or Adivasi person a claim to any rupee of it. Whether a court could review how a scheme was classified is a separate question, and I have not taken a lawyer's opinion on it. A promise, a scheme and an enforceable right are three different things, and the sub-plan is the second.
The Act does carry a test of its own, in section 15, and it has two halves. A direct and quantifiable benefit is shown for four guarantees. The "potential to bridge the gaps in the development" is where the whole argument lies. Additionality is my word for a strict reading of that phrase: a payment bridges a gap only if it gives the family something its neighbour does not get. The statute does not use the word, and a looser reading is open. A lawyer for the Government could say that ₹2,000 is a larger part of a poorer household's income, so the same payment closes some of the distance even when everyone receives it. That is the best legal argument for the Government. I have not seen it made, and it would need evidence that Dalit and Adivasi households are in fact gaining ground. So I offer additionality as a test of policy. I do not say the law imposes it.
The phrase that matters in Article 46 is "special care". The guarantee treats the Dalit woman exactly as it treats her neighbour, and that equal treatment is a good thing in itself. Special care is something more than equal treatment. On 25 November 1949, the day before the Constitution was adopted, Dr B.R. Ambedkar told the Constituent Assembly: "On the 26th of January 1950, we are going to enter into a life of contradictions." "In politics we will have equality and in social and economic life we will have inequality."³⁴ The guarantee belongs to the first half of his sentence. It pays each woman the same, as each citizen has one vote. The sub-plan was written for the second half. When the first is counted as the second, the contradiction he named is answered in the accounts and nowhere else. That is my reading, and a reader may weigh it differently.
A student of development economics would add a fair point for the other side. Universal schemes miss fewer poor people than targeted ones, because nobody has to prove a caste or an income to a clerk. About a quarter of Gruha Lakshmi's women are SC or ST, which matches their share of the people. So the guarantee does reach Dalit and Adivasi women in proportion. A sub-plan asks for more than proportion, and whether more is still owed is a question of values on which the Constitution has taken a side. On results I can say little. Payments, counts and allocations are outputs. Whether Dalit and Adivasi families are better schooled, housed or employed because of this fund is an outcome, and I found no study that measures it for Karnataka.
A study is now planned. On 29 October 2026 the cabinet is reported to have approved a survey called Project K-Monitor, led by the Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority. It is to cover the five guarantees in all 224 Assembly constituencies, with about 1.6 lakh respondents over eight months, at a cost of about ₹14 crore⁴¹. I rely on a summary of the decision and have not read the order. A planned survey is not a result. If it reports separately for SC and ST households, it could answer the question this article cannot.
An accountant would call the sub-plan a restricted fund and would ask of it what is asked of any restricted fund: what was bought with it that would not otherwise have been bought? The accounts of the sub-plan cannot answer, because they record where a rupee was booked and not what it added. And a student of politics would see why the label has lasted under two governments. The budget speech announces ₹44,632 crore for SC and ST welfare, and the figure is true. The cost of the label is seen only by legislators from those communities. They objected inside the BJP when it governed and inside the Congress when it governed, and each time their own party answered them as Yediyurappa and Mahadevappa did.
Each repair moves a cost to someone
None of the repairs below is free, and the first is the dearest. If the guarantees could no longer be charged, the law would still require 24.1% of the plan to be booked for SCs and STs. About ₹15,000 crore a year of new targeted spending would have to come from a general budget that is already in revenue deficit. That means more borrowing, less of something else, or a phased change over several years. I set that out so that nobody reads the table as costless. Each fix is my proposal. None is proven where I say the evidence is thin.
The problem | The repair | Who can act | Where it is done | How it can fail |
The guarantee charge adds nothing for the family | Write a rule for the second test of section 15: count a general scheme only for what SC and ST beneficiaries receive over and above the general entitlement | The State Council, by a rule under the Act. The Legislature, by amendment | I found no state law that spells this out. Section 15 states the aim and leaves the measure open | Departments cannot design ₹15,000 crore of targeted schemes in a year, and the money is parked |
It is not stated which words of clause (c) cover power, grain and bus travel | Publish the classification of each scheme under the clause, with the legal opinion relied on | The Nodal Agency and the Law Department | Not done, on what I found | An opinion written to fit the decision already taken |
The charge can run ahead of 24.1% of a scheme's cost, and ahead of the count | Cap each year's charge at the lower of 24.1% of the scheme's cost and the counted beneficiaries multiplied by the entitlement | Social Welfare and Finance Departments | Karnataka itself, for Gruha Lakshmi in 2025-26 | Counts are supplied by the departments that gain from them. They need an outside check |
Shakti is charged with no count | Charge nothing until a survey of riders gives a share, with route coverage by district | Transport and Social Welfare Departments | The department proposed a cap for want of data in 2025 | A survey costs money, and hamlets without buses stay unserved |
The duties in sections 6 and 26 are not visibly met | Publish, for each year since 2014, whether the social audit was done and the annual report placed, and put scheme, district and beneficiary details on the portal | The Nodal Agency | The Act has required it since 2013. Telangana's Act has like duties | A portal can be built and left empty. I have not checked how Telangana's works |
The special audit has no terms or date | Issue a written order with a deadline, terms that cover both clauses and both governments, and publication in full | The Chief Minister and the State Council | Announced in November 2026. No order seen | Institutions chosen by the audited may find little |
Unspent money is parked in March | Count money as spent when it reaches a beneficiary, and make up any shortfall in the next year | The Legislature and the Finance Department | Telangana: the unspent amount "shall be compensated in the next financial year" | The backlog rolls forward and grows |
Corporations get most or all of their grant in the last quarter | Quarterly ceilings on releases, so that no more than a set share goes out after December | The Finance Department | An ordinary treasury tool. I cite no state that applies it to these corporations | Departments that start slowly lose money they could have used |
Two ledgers disagree on anganwadi money, and Union money goes unused | Reconcile the State's accounts with the scheme's account each quarter, and spend the first instalment of PM-AJAY so that the rest is released | Women and Child Development, Social Welfare and Finance Departments | The auditor has asked for the first | A reconciliation shows the gap and does not fill it |
Sources: the Act⁵, the Telangana Act³², and the reports and audit cited in earlier Parts. Narrowing or scrapping clause (c), which the Legislature's committee asked for in 2024, is not in the table as a separate row. Closing it at once, while targeted schemes spend as they do now, would turn a problem of labels into a problem of unspent money.
The lenses used in this article can be gathered in one place.
Lens | The question it asks | What this article shows | A first reading, which is mine |
Law | Does the Act allow it, and who can enforce the fund? | Clause (c) names five sectors. Section 15 sets two tests. No person has a claim on the fund | Not held unlawful. Open on three schemes and on the second test. Whether a court can review the classification needs a lawyer's opinion |
Philosophy | Is equal treatment the same as special care? | Both women receive ₹2,000 | Equal treatment was delivered. Special care was booked |
Development economics | Does an earmark add anything? | A third of the fund is assigned to a benefit that all who qualify receive | An earmark protects only what would not otherwise be bought. No local study tests this |
Accounting | Where is the rupee booked, and what did it add? | One payment, two labels. Budget figures, not audited ones | The accounts record the label and cannot show the addition |
Gender | What does the payment do in a woman's hands? | Counts of women paid. No measure of control or use | Possibly more than the sum suggests. Not measured |
Business and enterprise | Can a borrower plan on this money? | Corporations for the Scheduled Castes received their whole grant in the last quarter | A lender without steady funds cannot lend steadily |
Federalism | What is the Union's part? | Union schemes were booked to the fund. PM-AJAY money was withheld | Shared. The Union's own budget is untested here |
Politics | Who sees the cost of the label? | SC and ST legislators objected under both governments | Those who see it have had the least say over the budget |
Ending — "There is no point in blaming those who were there earlier"
On Thursday 12 November 2026 the council met again at Vikasa Soudha, under a different Chief Minister. D.K. Shivakumar has held the office since 3 June 2026. The subject was the action plan for 2026-27: ₹44,631 crore over 451 schemes of 34 departments²⁹. "It is our government's intention that ₹44,631 crore allocated for SCSP/TSP scheme should reach the beneficiaries," he said⁴⁰.
Three reports of the meeting agree on two decisions²⁹ ³⁹ ⁴⁰. A group of ministers under the Deputy Chief Minister, G. Parameshwara, is to review the two sub-plans with the Finance Department: whether schemes overlap, whether some should change, and how the hostels are run. PTI reports that it was to report within two to three days³⁹. And the council agreed to a special audit, which PTI says Parameshwara proposed, of what has been spent "over the years" and how many lives it has changed. One report says reputed institutions will do it. Every beneficiary is to be documented, to prevent duplication. The Chief Minister added: "There is no point in blaming those who were there earlier."²⁹ None of the three reports mentions the guarantees or clause (c). None gives a date for the audit. I have seen no written order, so I call the audit announced. As of 16 November 2026 I found no report of what the group of ministers recommended.
The announcement is to the Government's credit, and one plain remark belongs beside it. The Act has asked for "at least annual social auditing" of this money since 2013, and for a report to the Legislature every year⁵. I looked on the sub-plan cell's website and in press reports and found no social audit published for any year, under either party. That is a missing public record. It does not show that no audit was done. If the yearly audits were done, they should be published. If they were not, the special audit is in part the work that was missed. Parameshwara chaired the committee that wrote the Congress manifesto of 2023³⁶. The man whose committee promised the guarantees now leads the review of the fund to which a third of their cost for SC and ST families is booked. Nobody is better placed to ask the Finance Department how each scheme was classified.
The three readings of July 2024 are still on the table. The Government said the money reached the families, and its counts support it for four schemes out of five. The Commission asked for an explanation, and I have found none. The Legislature's committee said misuse, and counted ten years that include the BJP's four. An audit can settle the amounts and how each scheme was classified. The question underneath is one of purpose.
The law never promised a Dalit woman a second ₹2,000. It promised that a share of the plan would be spent to close the distance between her and her neighbour. If the payment that both of them receive is counted as that share, what is left that was meant to close the distance?
More from Satyameva Jayate · Karnataka: Two Months Missing — Did Karnataka's Five Guarantees Reach the People They Named? and The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?
Words to keep
The rupee reaches her. Whether the reservation does is the question.
One scheme, two labels.
A canal needed no beneficiary.
Equal treatment was delivered. Special care was booked.
An earmark protects a group only when it pays for something that would not have been bought without it.
Equal sums neither prove nor disprove that a gap was narrowed.
The same rule gives both results.
Grain does not become land.
Sources
"Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India on State Finances for the year 2024-25, Government of Karnataka (Report No. 2 of 2026)", CAG, tabled 26 March 2026. https://cag.gov.in/en/audit-report/details/124514
"Accounts at a Glance 2024-25, Government of Karnataka", CAG. https://cag.gov.in/uploads/state_accounts_report/account-report-5-Accounts-at-a-Glance-English-2024-25-069a7f1b732a974-28310047.pdf
"Finance Accounts Volume I 2024-25, Government of Karnataka", CAG. https://cag.gov.in/uploads/state_accounts_report/account-report-2-Finance-Accounts-Vol-I-2024-25-government-of-karnataka-06948f82bb28817-62582478.pdf
"K'taka forced to cut down its funds for nutrition, local bodies due to increasing in subsidies: CAG", PTI in ThePrint, 26 March 2026. https://theprint.in/india/ktaka-forced-to-cut-down-its-funds-fur-nutrition-local-bodies-due-to-increasing-in-subsidies-cag/2889749
Karnataka Scheduled Castes Sub-Plan and Tribal Sub-Plan (Planning, Allocation and Utilization of Financial Resources) Act, 2013 (Karnataka Act 65 of 2013), as amended by Karnataka Act 6 of 2024. Copy hosted by PRS Legislative Research. Sections 2, 6, 7, 13, 15, 24 and 26 are cited. https://prsindia.org/files/bills_acts/acts_states/karnataka/2013/2013KR65.pdf
SCSP and TSP Cell, Government of Karnataka, table of allocation and expenditure from 2014-15, read in November 2026. https://www.scsptsp.karnataka.gov.in/
"Karnataka govt under fire over decision to use SC/ST funds for other schemes", The News Minute, 4 August 2023. https://www.thenewsminute.com/karnataka/karnataka-govt-under-fire-over-decision-use-scst-funds-other-schemes-180644
"Siddaramaiah government looks to use ₹11,000 crore SCP/TSP funds to implement poll guarantees", The South First, 2 August 2023. https://thesouthfirst.com/karnataka/siddaramaiah-government-looks-to-use-₹11000-crore-scp-tsp-funds-to-implement-poll-guarantees
"Govt to use 37% of SC/ST funds for guarantees", Deccan Herald, 6 July 2024. https://deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Fgovt-to-use-37-of-sc-st-funds-for-guarantees-3094766
"Karnataka minister defends diversion of SC/ST funds to guarantees", Deccan Herald, 19 July 2024. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/karnataka-minister-defends-diversion-of-scst-funds-to-guarantees-3113505
"Karnataka legislature committee slams state government for alleged misuse of SC/ST funds", The News Minute, 26 July 2024. https://www.thenewsminute.com/amp/story/karnataka/karnataka-legislature-committee-slams-state-government-for-alleged-misuse-of-scst-funds
"Armed with data, govt may allocate SC/ST sub-plan funds for 4 guarantees based on community numbers", Deccan Herald, 1 March 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Farmed-with-data-govt-may-allocate-scst-sub-plan-funds-for-4-guarantees-based-on-community-numbers-3427205
"Karnataka Budget takes away 6% less from SC/ST funds for guarantees this year", Deccan Herald, March 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/karnataka-budget-takes-away-6-less-from-scst-funds-for-guarantees-this-year-3439261
"SC/ST funds for guarantees: Karnataka's Opposition cries misuse, Congress government not amused", Deccan Herald, March 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Fscst-funds-for-guarantees-karnatakas-opposition-cries-misuse-congress-government-not-amused-3428013
"Congress government under fire again for diverting SC/ST welfare funds to guarantee schemes", Telangana Today, 29 July 2025. https://telanganatoday.com/congress-government-under-fire-again-for-diverting-sc-st-welfare-funds-to-guarantee-schemes
"HCM defends Rs 11k cr SC/ST funds for guarantees", Deccan Herald, 28 July 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/hcm-defends-rs-11k-cr-sc-st-funds-for-guarantees-3652892
"Karnataka minister warns of action against departments not furnishing SC/ST funds data", PTI in The Week, 20 August 2025. https://www.theweek.in/wire-updates/national/2025/08/20/mds20-ka-scst-funds-minister.html and "Diversion of SC/ST funds: Karnataka minister assures invoking penal provisions", Deccan Herald, August 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/diversion-of-scst-funds-karnataka-minister-assures-invoking-penal-provisions-3689556
"Funds under SCSP/TSP not misused, claims Minister H C Mahadevappa", Deccan Herald, 13 December 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/funds-under-scsptsp-not-misused-claims-minister-h-c-mahadevappa-3829522
"Karnataka Budget 2026-27: State govt allocates Rs 15,066 crore for guarantees from SCSP/TSP", Deccan Herald, 7 March 2026. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/karnataka-budget-2026-27-state-govt-allocates-rs-15066-crore-for-guarantees-from-scsptsp-3922489
"Karnataka: Diversion of SC/ST funds for guarantee schemes sparks outrage against state government", Organiser, 24 March 2026. https://organiser.org/2026/03/24/345342/bharat/karnataka-diversion-of-sc-st-funds-for-guarantee-schemes-sparks-outrage-against-state-government/
"Rs 7K-cr SC/ST funds 'diverted' for infra works in Karnataka", Deccan Herald, April 2022. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/st-funds-diverted-for-infra-works-in-karnataka-1102213.html
"SC/ST fund diversion: Siddaramaiah slams BJP govt", Deccan Herald, 21 April 2022. https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Fst-fund-diversion-siddaramaiah-slams-bjp-govt-1102618.html
"BSY says not even a paisa diverted from SC/ST funds", Deccan Herald, 2021. https://www.deccanherald.com/state/karnataka-politics/bsy-says-not-even-a-paisa-diverted-from-sc/st-funds-1004274.html
"Karnataka unlikely to scrap deemed expenditure clause", Deccan Herald, 2023. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/karnataka-unlikely-to-scrap-deemed-expenditure-clause-1228392.html
"From PM Kisan to guarantees: how Dalit and tribal welfare funds are spent in Karnataka", The South First, 9 July 2024. https://thesouthfirst.com/karnataka/from-pm-kisan-to-guarantees-how-dalit-and-tribal-welfare-funds-are-spent-in-karnataka/
"Karnataka Budget Analysis 2026-27", PRS Legislative Research, March 2026. https://prsindia.org/budgets/states/karnataka-budget-analysis-2026-27
"Eight Bills passed, including ones on BBMP and recruitment exam", The Hindu via inkl, 2023. https://inkl.com/news/eight-bills-passed-including-ones-on-bbmp-and-recruitment-exam
"Rs 39,000 crore meant for Dalits used for guarantees: K'taka BJP demands minister's resignation", IANS in Lokmat Times, 19 December 2025. https://www.lokmattimes.com/national/rs-39000-crore-meant-for-dalits-used-for-guarantees-ktaka-bjp-demands-ministers-resignation/amp
Report of the meeting of the State SC and ST Development Council of 12 November 2026, The Bengaluru Live, 13 November 2026. https://thebengalurulive.com/karnataka-to-write-to-pm-ninth-schedule-sc-st-quota-hike-social-audit-scsp-tsp/
"Revised Guidelines for Implementation of Scheduled Castes Sub-Plan and Tribal Sub-Plan", report of the Task Force chaired by Dr Narendra Jadhav, Planning Commission, 2010. https://niti.gov.in/sites/default/files/2019-12/SCSP_TSP_Revised_Guidelines_2010.pdf
Planning Commission, Office Memorandum on the Scheduled Castes Sub-Plan and Tribal Sub-Plan, 11 February 2014. Copy hosted by the National Commission for Scheduled Castes. https://ncsc.nic.in/storage/orders/MeK4IVMe9QcbWWq5fWJbgIpmtac8oxKW2Y2Ld2XD.pdf
Telangana State Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Special Development Fund (Planning, Allocation and Utilization of Financial Resources) Act, 2017. Copy hosted by PRS Legislative Research. Sections 5, 11, 14, 20 and 28 are cited. https://prsindia.org/files/bills_acts/acts_states/telangana/2017/2017Telangana18.pdf
Constitution of India, Article 46, with the record of its adoption on 23 November 1948. https://www.constitutionofindia.net/articles/article-46-promotion-of-educational-and-economic-interests-of-scheduled-castes-scheduled-tribes-and-other-weaker-sections/
Dr B.R. Ambedkar, speech in the Constituent Assembly, 25 November 1949, as reproduced by the Supreme Court Observer. https://www.scobserver.in/journal/the-doctors-wise-words-on-25-november-1949/
Tarhan Feyzioglu, Vinaya Swaroop and Min Zhu, "A Panel Data Analysis of the Fungibility of Foreign Aid", The World Bank Economic Review, volume 12, number 1, 1998, pages 29 to 58. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/514331468149391238/pdf/772610JRN0WBER0Box0377301B00PUBLIC0.pdf
"Assembly Election Karnataka, Manifesto 2023: Sarva Janangada Shanthiya Thota", Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee, 2023. 25-page edition. Pages 5 and 15 are cited. Page numbers are those of the PDF.
Bharatiya Janata Party, Karnataka Assembly election manifesto 2023 (English), with the running title "Samruddha Karanatakakke BJP Ye Bharavase". 48 pages. PDF page 18, which is printed page 04, is cited.
Janata Dal (Secular), "Janata Pranalike 2023" (Kannada). 36 pages. Page 9 is cited. English renderings are the author's.
"Group of Ministers to review implementation of schemes for SC/ST: CM Shivakumar", PTI in ThePrint, 12 November 2026. https://theprint.in/india/group-of-ministers-to-review-implementation-of-schemes-for-sc-st-cm-shivakumar/3097470/
"Karnataka To Ask PM Modi For Ninth Schedule Shield For Enhanced SC/ST Quota After HC Ruling", Outlook, 13 November 2026. https://www.outlookindia.com/national/karnataka-to-ask-pm-modi-for-ninth-schedule-shield-for-enhanced-scst-quota-after-hc-ruling
"Karnataka Approves Project K-Monitor Survey", GKToday, 29 October 2026. https://www.gktoday.in/karnataka-approves-project-k-monitor-survey/
How I wrote this
What I read in the original. The Comptroller and Auditor General's report on Karnataka's State Finances for 2024-25: the cost of the guarantees, the sentence on schemes that lost money, the review of the Social Welfare grant, Appendix 2.15 on releases to corporations, the PM-AJAY finding and Table 2.18 on the anganwadi scheme. The auditor's Accounts at a Glance and Finance Accounts for the same year. The 2013 Act with its 2024 amendment, and the Telangana Act of 2017, both in copies hosted by PRS Legislative Research and not in the Gazette. The sub-plan cell's table of allocation and spending. The Planning Commission's guidelines of 2010 and its memorandum of 2014. Article 46. The three manifestos of 2023. The World Bank study on fungibility.
What rests on press reports. Every year-wise figure for sub-plan money assigned to the guarantees. These are budget and action-plan figures and not amounts spent. The beneficiary counts tabled in the Legislative Council. The National Commission's letter and the Legislature committee's report, neither of which I have read in the original. The figure of ₹7,885.32 crore for 2018 to 2021, the Jal Jeevan Mission charge and the farm schemes charged in 2022-23. The statements of Siddaramaiah, Yediyurappa, Karjol, Mahadevappa, Narayanaswamy and Siddi. The council meeting of 12 November 2026, from three reports. Project K-Monitor, from a summary of the cabinet's decision. The split of 24.1% into 17.15% and 6.95%, since the Act prints no percentage.
What I have not seen or could not confirm. The State's sub-plan budget volumes, and so any figure for what was finally spent on the guarantees under the sub-plan. The Assembly reply said to give ₹9,797 crore as the amount used in 2024-25. Why two reports differ on the 2026-27 figure. Which words of clause (c) the Government relies on for each guarantee, and the rules made under the Act. Whether the yearly social audits and reports that the Act requires were done in any year. Whether the audit findings on the welfare departments concern money booked under the sub-plan. The data behind ₹7,885.32 crore and its split between the coalition and the BJP government. The Minister's figures of ₹8,000 crore and ₹4,000 crore. Who chaired the Legislature's committee and in which House its report was placed. The State's reply to the National Commission. Whether the Congress manifesto's ₹1,000 crore fund for SC entrepreneurs was set up. Any court order on the practice. Any count of hostel seats, scholarships, land grants or anganwadi beneficiaries against those eligible. Any written order for the special audit, or the report of the group of ministers. The cabinet order on Project K-Monitor. The units of the sub-plan cell's table, which I read as crore of rupees.
Quotations. Quotations from the audit, the two Acts, the Planning Commission, Article 46 and the manifestos are from the documents. Ambedkar's words are from a reproduction of his speech and not from the printed Debates. Quotations from ministers, leaders and the committee are as newspapers reported them. The JD(S) promise is given in my English, not in the party's words.
Readings that are mine. That the sub-plan charge adds nothing to what an eligible SC or ST family would receive anyway. Additionality as a strict reading of section 15, which the Act does not impose in that word. The table that sets each guarantee against clause (c) and section 15. The image of one scheme under two labels, and the use of the fungibility study as a lens. All arithmetic: the shares of the fund, the four-budget totals, the charge as a share of the guarantees' audited cost, the Gruha Lakshmi cross-check, the share of SC and ST households in Gruha Jyothi, the Adivasi shares, the remainder after the guarantees, the 9.5% for deemed expenditure and the sum of the BJP years. The comparison of the two governments. The reading of Article 46 and of Ambedkar's speech. The nine repairs and the estimate that the first would need about ₹15,000 crore a year. The inference about why the Finance Department uses this fund.
How the same test was applied to others. I put one question to both governments: was reserved money charged to spending not designed for SCs and STs alone? The record says yes for both, by different clauses and at different scales. For the BJP years I recorded the fall and recovery of the fund, the high share shown as spent, the Union farm schemes charged to it, and the refusal to remove clause (d) when the party's own SC and ST legislators asked. I noted that 2018-19 and part of 2019-20 belonged to a Congress and JD(S) coalition. The test of the Union government is thin: I recorded the Union schemes charged to the State's fund and the PM-AJAY money withheld, and I did not test the Union's own budget.
What I did not do. I did not speak to hostel students, borrowers from the corporations, anganwadi workers, women who receive the guarantees or families in hamlets without bus routes. I did not put questions to the Nodal Agency or to the Social Welfare, Finance or Energy Departments, and the Government has had no chance to reply to this article. All of that should be done before the next quarterly update. I have not taken a lawyer's opinion on clause (c) or on what a court could review. The article names no person as accused of an offence.

Comments